Forum Question & Answers

A while back I asked the members of the Trollslayer group to send me any questions they would like to ask Bill  and these questions were then compiled into one long list and passed onto Bill to answer. This Q&A is the end result. 

I would like to thank the following members for putting forward their questions and the initials in the brackets identify who asked which one. 

 

Robert Clark (RC)
Morgan Kelly  (MK)
Warren Beattie (WB)
Alex Samarchi (AS)
Dion Thomas (DT)
Robbie Borders  (RB)
David Adkins (DA)
Zack Golden  (ZG)
Leonchik Prokhorov (LP)
Aleeha R.Travis (ART)
John McLintock (JMcL)

 

Anyway, simply click the question and it will take you to the relevent answer or go here to view the entire Q&A....

 

 

1. The earlier editions of Warhammer portrayed the High Elves as being very Melnibončan in character. They weren't keen on 'work', and preferred to spend their time pursuing leisurely activities or pursuing court intrigue. How did the more clean-cut High Elves of 4th edition come about, and do you think there is any legacy of the old background there? Will we see new sides to the High Elves should the Tyrion & Teclis books ever see the light of day? (RC)

2. As a fantasy and 40K player, I always like to know the abilities of weapons being used. That said, where did Gotrek get his axe from, and what runes are inscribed on it? (MK)

3. Also, where did Felix get his sword from. (MK)

4. Also, who created each weapon and for what purpose were they created? (MK)

5. The slayer engineer (Malakai) has created some neat things, what does he (the slayer) feel is his best creation? (MK)

6. What does he (Malakai) consider his worst creation? (MK)

7. Why did Snorri run spikes through his head? Is he really as ignorant as he acts? (MK)

8. Felix and Gotrek are wanted throughout the empire, expecially Felix who was framed for robbery, why is there not a witch hunter or investigators tracking him down... (MK)

9. Can we expect some side stories about Ragnar? (MK)

10. Has Ragnar ever done anything he regrets? (MK)

11. In Space Wolf, Ragnar fights an Aspiring champion of the thousand suns who gets sealed in the mountain, (if I remember that right) then he fights another Aspiring champion that he sends back to the warp with the sacred spear... Will he ever best a Chaos Champion, or is he doomed to just barely excape with his life knowing the threat is still out there? (MK)

12. Can we expect to see Ragnar on a Space Hulk? Will he, or did he ever strap a jump pack on his back...(space wolfs hate jump packs, and teleporters because they can't keep their feet on the ground. (MK)

13. Will we ever find out precisely what happened to Janus Darke on Typhon? (WB)

14. Snorri any plans for cover art would love to see that slayer for once. I can only imagine what he looks like!! (AS)

15. Any more stories involving surrounding characters like Max and Malakai (where is that dwarf)? (AS)

16. How many books does he have planned (and how many does GW have planned)? (AS)

17. Will gotrek rub his finger down his ax anymore it was absent from Vampireslayer and other books.(AS)

18. Book titles? (AS)

19. Thanquol.. He was absent from the last book was he not? Will he come back in the next book? (AS)

20. In the novel Space Wolf, as soon as the aspirants were deemed worthy they became Blood Claws instead of Scouts. What are your thoughts on this? I only ask because you once wrote the short story 'In the Belly of the Beast' in issue 10 of Inferno about Space Wolf Scouts... (DT)

21. Will we ever see a confrontation between Ragnar and Kharn the Betrayer by any chance? I don't expect an answer to this one to be honest :p (DT)

22. How long did the story Wolf Riders take to write, from initial concept to finished? (RC)

23. There is a passage in the novel Beasts in Velvet where one of the characters has a rememberance of seeing Gotrek in action at the siege of Praag. The novel was published in '93 where as your actual account of Gotrek's involvement didn't arrive until 2001. Did you create the story of the second Praag siege? Were the other authors informed of your intention to chronicle the events? How long did you have the ideas for these events? (RB)

24. You wrote the short story of Deathwing for the expansion to Space Hulk, 10 years or so ago, do you have any plans to return to the Dark Angels chapter in the future? (DA)

25. Can we expect to see some good old slaughter fests in GIANTSLAYER? A few like in the earlier books possibly. Thats the only thing I thought was missing in VAMPIRESLAYER. I guess I just need to feed that violent side of my brain :D (ZG)

26. Will there be any chance to see some new characters and adversaries in the space wolf series? (MK)

27. Will you be adding any new info in the Farseer and Space Wolf series about the necrons and their dealings with the Eldar of long ago, or the Space Wolves? (MK)

28. I am currently reading the Konrad series by David Ferring, he weaves a good web on enticement. He also says that nothing happens coincidentally. What is your take on that statement as far as your novels go? I ask this because it seems that there is alot of 'white noise' around the characters that doesn't get attention. (MK)

29. Will Felix & Gotrek return to Altorf in their travels? May be they will meet the Emperor himself... what do you think of such possibility? (LP)

30. Will we see more Otto Jaeger? (LP)

31. Did you think about future adventures of G&F? I.e. what book title must we expect next? Where the adventures will take them? (LP)

32. Is Bill aware of any more future plans to include 40k crossovers with Warhammer Fantasy?  By that I mean we have the old ones and the 40k 'artifacts' from the Albion campain (which I assume will be a part of Bill's Giantslayer book) but beyond Giantslayer are there more plans? (ART)

33. I've noticed, especially in Dragonslayer, how the Dwarf culture seems to stress that any kind of failure or humiliation ends in a Dwarf taking up the Slayer vow and marching off into the wastes. And yet, in Trollslayer, we hear of Faragrim, who we discover did some less than honourable deeds and yet didn't take the oath. Clearly not all Dwarfs feel as strongly tied to their honour as Gotrek and company. Have you got any thoughts on this? (RC)

34. Will we ever get to know a little more about the fate of Leman Russ? Maybe he'll appear in a vision to Ragnar during his exile...what do you think of such a possibility? (DT)

35. In 2nd edition Codex Space Wolves, some of the characters in the Ragnar novels featured in the colour texts and in the Special Character sections. By reading these we get to find out what happened to these characters later on in their lives...namely Strybjorn and Berek Thunderfist. My question is, are you planing to stay true to the events described in the old Space Wolves codex in future Ragnar books? (DT)

36. Given the strong ties between the two chapters, will we ever see the Space Wolves fighting alongside the Dark Angels in a future Ragnar book? What are your thoughts on such a possibility? (DT)

37. You've mentioned several times the outlines you write for the Black Library for GW approval. How copious are the notes you take before setting down to write your stories? (JMcL)

38. Do ever find yourself beginning a story somewhere in the middle, then working back to a suitable beginning? (JMcL)

39. Can you keep the Ragnar saga going as long as the Trollslayer epic? (JMcL)

40. Are you the sort of reader who keeps track of the pagecount while you read, so that you can figure out how much you've read as you plow through? (JMcL)

 

[ Back to FAQ ]            [ Top ]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Trollslayer Forum Q&A

1. The earlier editions of Warhammer portrayed the High Elves as being very Melnibončan in character. They weren't keen on 'work', and preferred to spend their time pursuing leisurely activities or pursuing court intrigue. How did the more clean-cut High Elves of 4th edition come about, and do you think there is any legacy of the old background there? Will we see new sides to the High Elves should the Tyrion & Teclis books ever see the light of day?

I don't think the two views of Elves are mutually exclusive. The 4th edition simply placed a different emphasis on what was described and what was not.  I think this was done partially to heighten the contrast between the High Elves and the Dark Elves. 

Personally I think that although the two peoples seem to be mirror images of each other- they are essentially the same. They both have just decided to emphasise certain facets of their characters- often in reaction to each other. The split between the two factions polarised Elvish society by forcing them to define themselves in opposition to each other, although they have far more in common than they would admit.

I don't think it states anywhere in 4th edition or beyond that High Elves are not interested in court intrigue. Given the nature of their society- split between two courts – Phoenix King and Everqueen- and given the semi-elective nature of the office of Phoenix King, it's hard to imagine them not doing a lot of plotting.

Nor do I recall it stating anywhere in 4th edition that High Elves were keen on work. Personally I see the High Elves as a fairly conservative warrior-aristocracy although this begs the question of who actually does the work in their society. I can see certain things being done by sorcery but I suspect a class of thralls, servants or slaves must do others. It's something that still needs to be talked about with the folk at the Studio before I write about it.

I see the Elves as being disdainful of other races-particularly dwarves- a bit like the aristocratic class of the British and Russian Empires in the 19th century. They might be square jawed in the sense that heroes of Victorian Empire were but that does not make them nice people. Given their extremely long life spans, their physical beauty, the depths of their scholarship and culture and the power of their magic, they can give lots of good arguments to support their prejudices  but they are still prejudices. 

I also see  Elves  as malicious and prone to intriguing. Again, given their extremely long life spans, they have plenty of time for vendettas and feuds.  It fills up the time.  If and when I ever get round to doing the Tyrion and Teclis books, these ideas will almost certainly be reflected in the text.

 

 

2.  As a fantasy and 40K player, I always like to know the abilities of weapons being used. That said, where did Gotrek get his axe from, and what runes are inscribed on it?

Gotrek acquired the axe in the Chaos wastes. The runes are as yet undeciphered but they appear to be pretty powerful and to have something to do with smiting Chaos. They also seem to have some protective function.

 

 

3. Also, where did Felix get his sword from.

He acquired it  in  Karag Eight Peaks. For more details see The Dark Beneath The World in Trollslayer.

 

 

4. Also, who created each weapon and for what purpose were they created??

I am not at liberty to divulge this information at the present moment. However all will be revealed in the fullness of time-certainly about the Axe anyway.

 

 

5. The slayer engineer (Malakai) has created some neat things, what does he (the slayer) feel is his best creation?

Malakai currently thinks the airship is his best creation although doubtless, like all demented creators his next creation will always be his best.

 

 

6.  What does he (Malakai) consider his worst creation?

He feels a little guilty about the steamship that sank taking its entire crew with it.  He's not too proud of his first airship either.

 

 

7. Why did Snorri run spikes through his head? Is he really as ignorant as he acts?

Snorri ran the spikes into his head when he was drunk. He has forgotten exactly why at this moment, although he might remember some day. Snorri is not as ignorant as he acts, he is more ignorant.

 

 

8. Felix and Gotrek are wanted throughout the empire, expecially Felix who was framed for robbery, why is there not a witch hunter or investigators tracking him down...

The Empire is a big place. Gotrek and Felix are currently wanted in Altdorf for their part in the Window Tax riots and doubtless as word gets out they will be wanted in others. However, the pair move around a lot, have been to lots of places outside the Empire, and are not the easiest of folk to track down. It would be a pretty determined witch hunter who would follow them into the Chaos wastes for example, and that is assuming he could track an airship. That’s not to say that this will not cause the pair of them trouble in future ...   

 

 

9. Can we expect some side stories about Ragnar?

Possibly. Right now I am concentrating on the novels  but there's always the possibility of some short stories.

 

 

10. Has Ragnar ever done anything he regrets?

Like everybody else, yes.  A fair number of these things appear in the first three books.

 

 

11. In Space Wolf, Ragnar fights an Aspiring champion of the thousand suns who gets sealed in the mountain, (if I remember that right) then he fights another Aspiring champion that he sends back to the warp with the sacred spear... Will he ever best a Chaos Champion, or is he doomed to just barely excape with his life knowing the threat is still out there?

As Ragnar becomes more experienced and more deadly, his chances of taking out a Chaos Champion increase. Bear in mind that during the period of most of these stories he is still a relatively young warrior. His best days are ahead of him.

 

 

12. Can we expect to see Ragnar on a Space Hulk? Will he, or did he ever strap a jump pack on his back...(space wolfs hate jump packs, and teleporters because they can't keep their feet on the ground.

Most of these things happened in Ragnar’s Claw. Certainly I seem to recall a Space Hulk and a teleporter. Just because Space Wolves dislike things doesn’t mean they won’t do them when the mission demands it.

 

 

13. Will we ever find out precisely what happened to Janus Darke on Typhon?

Not in the foreseeable (or should that be Farseeable future) but anything is possible in the long run.

 

 

14. Snorri any plans for cover art would love to see that slayer for once. I can only imagine what he looks like!!

Too horrible for words, most likely! I don’t know of any plans to do a cover featuring Snorri but that does not mean one will not happen.

 

 

15. Any more stories involving surrounding characters like Max and Malakai (where is that dwarf)?

The possibility of doing stories featuring a number of the characters from the series has been discussed but as yet nothing has come of it. I have toyed with doing more stories featuring a squad of slayers but it sounded like a bad cop show (Slayer Squad).

 

 

16. How many books does he have planned (and how many does GW have planned)?

GW had initially planned for 10 but I can see the series exceeding that simply because we are now at book 7 and I still have plenty of ideas for tales before Gotrek meets his well-deserved doom. On the other hand, if GW put their foot down and say 10’s your lot, Bill, 10 it will have to be. In an ideal world I would say 12 books but who can tell?

 

 

17.  Will gotrek rub his finger down his ax anymore it was absent from Vampireslayer and other books.

I am sure he will. He was most likely doing it in Vampireslayer as well, I just forgot to describe it?

 

 

18. Book titles?

A bit cryptic this one! I assume you mean titles for upcoming Gotrek and Felix books. Licheslayer is a likely one. Kinslayer is another. Elfslayer would make Gotrek happy. And of course, there is the ever popular Snotlingslayer-just kidding.

 

 

19. Thanquol.. He was absent from the last book was he not? Will he come back in the next book?

The Grey Seer will return as soon as he can. He actually put in a brief appearance in Vampireslayer but was edited out for reasons of space- and the fact he was not doing very much. Some day I would like to do a novel or at very least a novella featuring the Grey Seer most likely set in Skavenblight

 

 

20. In the novel Space Wolf, as soon as the aspirants were deemed worthy they became Blood Claws instead of Scouts. What are your thoughts on this? I only ask because you once wrote the short story 'In the Belly of the Beast' in issue 10 of Inferno about Space Wolf Scouts...

Regarding the similarities between the characters in the Inferno story and the Space Wolf novels, there is a simple explanation. 'In the Belly of the Beast' was written as colour text for Advanced Space Crusade and promptly vanished into hyperspace. As far as I knew the files were lost. When I wrote Space Wolf  I never expected  to see "Beast" in print and cheerfully re-used all the names and some of the characters from the story because they were good Space Wolf names and characters. Then somebody found the "beast" file and the story was reprinted in Inferno without anybody telling me until it was done. The way Blood Claws and Scouts have been portrayed and interact has indeed been changed from the way it was when "Beast" was first written. These things happen

 

 

21. Will we ever see a confrontation between Ragnar and Kharn the Betrayer by any chance? I don't expect an answer to this one to be honest :p

We might, but it will be far in the future. We’re more likely to see a team up/confrontation/ slaughterfest with Kharn and Zarghan Ironfist from Farseer.

 

 

22. How long did the story Wolf Riders take to write, from initial concept to finished?

No idea! Actually I must have had one once but it was a very long time ago and I have forgotten. A few weeks I would imagine.

 

 

23. There is a passage in the novel Beasts in Velvet where one of the characters has a rememberance of seeing Gotrek in action at the siege of Praag. The novel was published in '93 where as your actual account of Gotrek's involvement didn't arrive until 2001. Did you create the story of the second Praag siege? Were the other authors informed of your intention to chronicle the events? How long did you have the ideas for these events?

This is a very convoluted tale. Many years ago during the first run of GW books- about 1990 I think-there were plans to do a big shared world type anthology something like Thieves World featuring many of the Warhammer characters of the day with lots of stories by different writers. This was discussed with lots of the writers but nothing ever came of it. I think Kim Newman/Jack Yeovil was foreshadowing the original anthology discussed. The idea stuck in my mind so I decided to do it myself in Beastslayer. Funny how these things work out. 

 

 

24. You wrote the short story of Deathwing for the expansion to Space  Hulk, 10 years or so ago, do you have any plans to return to the Dark Angels chapter in the future?

Not in the foreseeable future, no. I once had the cunning plan of doing a novel like Space Wolf for each of the four big chapters. Then I realised that this way lay madness.

 

 

25. Can we expect to see some good old slaughter fests in GIANTSLAYER? A few like in the earlier books possibly. Thats the only thing I thought was missing in VAMPIRESLAYER. I guess I just need to feed that violent side of my brain :D

Giantslayer should see a return to the body counts of yore. Chaos Warriors, scores of beastmen, minor demons, orcs, goblins, giants and more will provide fodder for the axe.

 

 

26. Will there be any chance to see some new characters and advisaries in the space wolf series?

Yes. The next Ragnar book is set at least partially on Earth and should introduce a whole new set of support characters and adversaries. There may even be some overlap with the Farseer series.

 

 

27. Will you be adding any new info in the Farseer and Space Wolf series about the necrons and their dealings with the Eldar of long  ago, or the Space Wolves?

No plans for it at the moment. Its one of those things I will need to sit down and discuss with the 40K team the next time I am in Nottingham.

 

 

28. I am currently reading the Konrad series by David Ferring, he weaves a good web on enticement. He also says that nothing happens coincidentally.What is your take on that statement as far as your novels go? I ask this because it seems that there is alot of 'white noise' around the characters that doesn't get attention.

Certainly Felix suspects that there is a pattern to events if you read the passages he writes. Whether he is correct or not, only time will tell. 

 

 

29. Will Felix & Gotrek return to Altorf in their travels? May be they will meet the Emperor himself...  what do you think of such possibility?

They might. Felix has family there. Of course there is the little matter of being wanted by the law. Will they meet the Emperor? Its certainly possible.

 

 

30. Will we see more Otto Jaeger?

Yes. Most likely in fairly distressing circumstances.

 

 

31. Did you think about future adventures of G&F? I.e. what book title must we expect next? Where the adventures will take them?

I would like them to visit Ulthuan, the Land of the Dead, Naggaroth and Lustria, not necessarily in that order. I also have a sneaking fondness for Tilea. Given the chance I would like to send them to Araby and Cathay, but those are long shots.

 

 

32. Is Bill aware of any more future plans to include 40k crossovers with Warhammer Fantasy?  By that I mean we have the old ones and the 40k 'artifacts' from the Albion campain (which I assume will be a part of Bill's Giantslayer book) but beyond Giantslayer are there more plans?

Nope, not that I have heard of but that does not mean there will be none. I too am quite fond of sorcery meets super-science and have been since the good old days of Hawkmoon and Karl Edward Wagner’s Kane novels.

 

 

33. I've noticed, especially in Dragonslayer, how the Dwarf culture seems to stress that any kind of failure or humiliation ends in a Dwarf taking up the Slayer vow and marching off into the wastes. And yet, in Trollslayer, we hear of Faragrim, who we discover did some less than honourable deeds and yet didn't take the oath. Clearly not all Dwarfs feel as strongly tied to their honour as Gotrek and company. Have you got any thoughts on this?

Like ourselves, Dwarves are individuals. Their culture may bring many social pressures to bear on them, but each of them can choose how they react to this in their own way. Also, much as dwarves would hate to admit this, I suspect a few of them must be cowards.

 

 

34. Will we ever get to know a little more about the fate of Leman Russ? Maybe he'll appear in a vision to Ragnar during his exile...what do you think of such a possibility?

Given the fact Ragnar lost his Spear, I hate to think what Leman might have to say to Ragnar but yes, I think there is some possibility of something like this happening.

 

 

35. In 2nd edition Codex Space Wolves, some of the characters in the Ragnar novels featured in the colour texts and in the Special Character sections. By reading these we get to find out what happened to these characters later on in their lives...namely Strybjorn and Berek Thunderfist. My question is, are you planing to stay true to the events described in the old Space Wolves codex in future Ragnar books?

Certainly in the case of Berek Thunderfist I am. I most likely will show it in considerable detail. In the case of Strybjorn, well, it’s a common enough name…

 

 

36. Given the strong ties between the two chapters, will we ever see the Space Wolves fighting alongside the Dark Angels in a future Ragnar book? What are your thoughts on such a possibility?

Once again, no immediate plans but I don’t rule it out. I like the Dark Angels as a Chapter-indeed my old epic army were Dark Angels-so it would be nice to get to grips with them.

 

 

37. You've mentioned several times the outlines you write for the Black Library for GW approval. How copious are the notes you take before setting down to write your stories?

Usually about 3-5000 words, with a detailed outline, descriptions of any major new characters, settings and plot devices. This is what the BL makes its approval decisions on. Usually during the course of writing the book though, I deviate quite considerably from these. No plan ever survives contact with the enemy and all that.

 

 

38. Do ever find yourself beginning a story somewhere in the middle, then working back to a suitable beginning?

Not often but it does happen. What is more common is coming up with a cool idea or links between characters as I write and then having to go back and foreshadow them.

 

 

39. Can you keep the Ragnar saga going as long as the Trollslayer epic?

I never used to think so, but actually, at the moment, the answer is yes. Strangely I found as soon as I started working on Farseer, lots of ideas for Ragnar came to me. Why this should be, I do not know. Certainly at the moment I can easily envision a trilogy about the quest for the Spear of Russ which is actually further ahead than I tend to plan with Gotrek and Felix.

 

 

40. Are you the sort of reader who keeps track of the pagecount while you read, so that you can figure out how much you've read as you plow through?

Not really but its one of those things you cant help but notice anyway. On one side of my thumb, the book gets thicker, the other thinner. 

 

[ Back to FAQ ]      [ Top  ]